Homemade Bailey’s Flavoured Marshmallows Recipe

Homemade Bailey’s Flavoured Marshmallows Recipe: we added Baileys to our homemade marshmallows for a delicious adult treat for the Bailey’s lover.

If you’re a fan of Bailey’s Irish Cream liquor, you’ll love these Bailey’s Irish Cream marshmallows.  These Baileys marshmallows are perfect for an adult in a mug of hot chocolate or just as a treat.

You might remember that I made a few different kinds of flavoured homemade marshmallows last week for my hot chocolate buffet -read all about it here. These were a real hit, and I felt like they needed their very own post so today I’m sharing my Bailey’s flavoured marshmallows recipe. They’re that special. 😉

Adult Treat

These marshmallows are an adults only treat.  With one cup of Bailey’s in them they do contain some alcohol, so keep these away from children.

Is It Hard To Make Homemade Marshmallows?

I know there are some of you out there a little intimidated by trying to make your own marshmallows, but they’re really not too hard, if you have a stand mixer. You will also need a candy thermometer. And just in case you’re wondering a candy thermometer is only 5-10 bucks.  A trip to a kitchen store is always fun.  The hardest part of the recipe is done by the stand mixer.  It really does all the work.  The second hardest part is reading the thermometer and getting the sugar mixture to the correct heat.  This part is important.  If the candy doesnt get to the right temperature it won’t set properly.  Take some care to watch the thermometer carefully as it reaches the right temperature and remove the mixture from the heart promptly once it does.

Cutting Your Marshmallows

Once your marshmallows are set overnight you can cut them up.  We cut quite large marshmallows, but you can make any size you want, from giant marshmallows to small ones or mini ones too.  Use a sharp knife to cut them,or a pizza wheel,  If it becomes sticky, wash it off in between cuts.   Coat the edges with more of the powdered sugar mixture.  Be sure to store your cut marshmallows in an airtight container so that they don’t dry out.

Toasted Marshmallows

If you want your marshmallows toasted, you can toast them over hot coals like you would with any marshmallows.  They aren’t quite as hard and dense as store bought marshmallows, and the warm marshmallow will fall of a toasting stick quite easily so do take care not to lose your precious marshmallow.  You can also use a blow torch in the kitchen to toast these, especially if you’re making grown up s’mores with them.

Chocolate Dipped Flavoured Marshmallows

I made several kinds of marshmallows when I made these, including some plain vanilla ones (just leave out the Baileys) and also some chocolate ones (leave out the Bailey’s and add 1/2 cup of cocoa to the finished marshmallows at the very end, pluss add 1/2 cup of cocoa to the powdered sugar and cornstarch mixture).  I packaged some of them up in some sweet mason jars for gift giving.  It’s the perfect way to really impress your peeps this Christmas. And, just to gild the lily, I dipped some in melted chocolate.

I just stacked up all three kinds on a lollipop stick and dipped them in melted chocolate.  I used milk chocolate for dipping, but these would also be really delicious dipped in dark chocolate.  You could also add some crushed graham cracker bits to the melted chocolate for a Baileys s’more inspired treat.

Perfect for Gift Giving

These were perfect to send to school with my kids for a teacher treat. Let’s just say they were well received. A+ for mommy. ;). They would be a really fun addition to a hot cocoa gift basket for adults too.  Or with all the other ingredients to make Baileys s’mores, like graham crackers and your favorite chocolate.  It’s also very fun to include your Bailey’s marshmallows as part of homemade cocktail kits, along with a bottle of Baileys Irish cream.  This indulgent treat desert is sure to be a hit with any Bailey’s fan.

With homemade Baileys marshmallows, life really is a party!

More Recipe Inspiration

You might also enjoy our Homemade Coffee Marshmallow recipe here.

Also check out our Homemade Caramel Apple recipe here.

You might also like our Pecan Butter Crunch Candy recipe here.